Please write a 1450-word critical review of the journal article titled
‘Eighteen-month-old infants show false belief understanding in an active helping
paradigm’
Article Reference: Buttelmann, D., Carpenter, M., & Tomasello, M. (2009).
Eighteen-month-old infants show false belief understanding in an active helping
paradigm. Cognition, 112(2), 337-342.
Eighteen-month-old infants show false belief understanding in an active helping
paradigm. Cognition, 112(2), 337-342.
Introduction
1. Background
2. Definitions
3. Description of
review ( 1. Provides good background
of the area and a good level of
context for the current review
2. Provides clear definitions for
most key concepts and terms
3. Gives a good description of
current review).
review ( 1. Provides good background
of the area and a good level of
context for the current review
2. Provides clear definitions for
most key concepts and terms
3. Gives a good description of
current review).
Summary
4. Detail
5. Explanation
6. Paraphrasing (4. Excellent and carefully
crafted detail is provided
from all sections of the
study manuscript 5. A clear and concise
summary of methodology
6. Clearly and
consistently paraphrased
the study description into your own words)
crafted detail is provided
from all sections of the
study manuscript 5. A clear and concise
summary of methodology
6. Clearly and
consistently paraphrased
the study description into your own words)
Evaluation
7.
Appropriateness
Appropriateness
8. Zone Model
9. Supporting
evidence (7. A good selection of points
chosen for evaluation
8. Sound evaluation of the
study which mostly follows the
zone model to zone 3
9. Consistent use of relevant
evidence to support
arguments made)
evidence (7. A good selection of points
chosen for evaluation
8. Sound evaluation of the
study which mostly follows the
zone model to zone 3
9. Consistent use of relevant
evidence to support
arguments made)
Conclusion
10. Synthesis
11. Future
research
directions
research
directions
12. Concluding
statement (10. Attempts to draw points
together into a summary
11. Suggests evidenced future
research directions 12. Provides a good concluding
statement regarding impact
and quality of target study)
statement (10. Attempts to draw points
together into a summary
11. Suggests evidenced future
research directions 12. Provides a good concluding
statement regarding impact
and quality of target study)